This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
Quality Magazine logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Quality Magazine logo
  • Home
  • The Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Digital Edition
    • Archives
    • How To Guide
    • Industry News
    • Subscribe
  • Web Exclusives
    • Blogs
    • NDT Exclusives
    • Quality Exclusives
    • Vision & Sensors
  • New Products
  • Channels
    • Management
    • Measurement
    • NDT
    • Quality 101
    • Software
    • Test & Inspection
    • Vision & Sensors
  • Markets
    • Aerospace
    • Automotive
    • Electronics
    • Energy
    • Green Manufacturing
    • Medical
    • Plastics
  • More
    • Leadership 100 Survey
    • Plant of the Year
    • Professional of the Year
    • Job Board
    • White Papers
    • Quality Store
    • Software Downloads
    • eCards
    • Product Spotlights
    • Industry Links
    • Sponsor Insights
    • Market Research
  • Multimedia
    • eNewsletter
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • Showcases
    • Image Galleries
    • Interactive Spotlights
  • Events
    • IMTS
    • Event Calendar
    • Quality Show
  • InfoCenters
    • Manage Quality, Risk & Compliance
    • Material Science Quality within Microscopy
    • Modern Quality Control with SPC
    • Process Control in Manufacturing
  • Directories
    • Buyers Guide
    • NDT Sourcebook
    • Take a Tour
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
Home » Opportunities and Challenges of Optical Metrology in Manufacturing
Measurement

Opportunities and Challenges of Optical Metrology in Manufacturing

The latest technological advances open new opportunities with the right approach and the right equipment.

MeasureB_sl1
Example of a classical measurement tool for machine vision. This method is time consuming and less accurate than modern machine vision systems can provide today. Source: Lumenera
MeasureB_sl2
Image 1. Quad Tap Mismatch. Source: Lumenera
MeasureB_sl3
Image 2. Quad Tap Matched. Source: Lumenera
MeasureB_sl4
Lumenera's High Performance Lt Camera Series with USB3. Source: Lumenera
MeasureB_sl1
MeasureB_sl2
MeasureB_sl3
MeasureB_sl4
January 1, 2015
Eric Ramsden
KEYWORDS 3-d metrology / CCD / CMOS / optical metrology
Reprints
No Comments

Optical metrology is a crucial tool used in industrial automation to increase productivity and quality levels via 100% inspection rates. Thanks to the latest leaps towards higher resolution and frame rates of image sensors accompanied by mature high-bandwidth camera interfaces like USB3.0, optical metrology today allows for very fast analysis of 2-D and 3-D objects with unprecedented accuracy. This article provides considerations and reasoning on how to select the right key system components, especially cameras, for different metrology applications.

System Parameters and Accuracy in Optical Metrology

The designs of optical metrology systems vary widely, depending on the application. However, lens, image sensor, and camera play the key role in all classic systems. Each component influences the performance of the system in quantitative and qualitative aspects. Quantitative parameters are the measurement accuracy in the 2-D image plane and in the third dimension, the depth, as well as the time required to capture and measure an object. Furthermore, one needs to take into account whether the target object is stationary or in motion (e.g. on a conveyor belt or handled by a robot). A qualitative parameter is the reliability of a measurement system. Despite varying environmental conditions, like temperature and lighting, measurement results shall be consistent and reproducible.  Also the failure rate of measurement operations itself, e.g. due to issues in camera electronics or software, is critical.

Regarding image sensor resolution, it is obvious that the number of pixels is directly proportional to the spatial resolution and accurate representation of the object. Unless one can ensure that the object and the camera are absolutely still during the exposure time of the sensor, a global shutter sensor is mandatory so that all pixels are captured and read out at the same time after the exposure is finished. With global shutter technology, no distortion is introduced by movements during the exposure. The standard approach of classic industrial camera design is to take a good sensor with CCD or CMOS global shutter technology, add various image enhancement features and capture modes and implement the camera in a low-cost design. 

Camera selection is often based on resolution, frame rate, minimum exposure time, and price criteria, which works well for applications in general inspection and presence detection like food and print quality verification or normal factory automation.  New innovations in image sensor designs and data interfaces are enabling camera manufacturers to produce cameras with increased resolutions coupled with higher frame rates. These innovations are increasing the range of applications that can leverage the new technologies for more precise inspection results.

Applications of Optical Metrology and Resulting Requirements

In 2-D geometrical metrology, a single camera is mounted orthogonally to the surface that shall be captured. When it comes to the analysis of the dimension, e.g., of flat metal sheets after cutting, milling, drilling and further processing steps, the sheets are moving on a conveyor. On top of the belt, a metrology camera is mounted and a typical range for the intended accuracy is 0.1mm. In such scenarios, the production output is often limited by the inspection capacities rather than by the production machines itself. Thus, cameras should be able to capture and measure the objects when they are moving at high speed (e.g. 2 meters per second).

This requires the camera to be very sensitive in order to allow for short exposure times. And since multiple objects per second are passing by the camera, a high frame rate needs to be delivered to the processing unit. Thus, a camera interface with high bandwidth is required. CameraLink used to be the industry standard before USB3.0 became common in consumer and industrial PCs. While USB3.0 is considered to be widespread and mature, the careful design of the camera chipset, the camera firmware, image buffers inside the camera, the software driver, as well as the selection of the host chipset are crucial to make sure that all frames that are captured by the camera are actually delivered and retained by the PC; otherwise, parts may slip through the inspection process. This is a core aspect of the “qualitative performance” parameters of a metrology system mentioned above.

Zero frame loss is critical when moving objects are measured by several cameras in order to obtain a 3-D model. For a correct 3-D representation, all cameras need to capture an image of the object at the same point in time. This can be accomplished via external trigger signals linked to the general purpose I/O port of the industrial cameras. Even more critical, all frames from up to four cameras have to be delivered reliably to a single host PC where all images are then combined. If a frame from just one camera is lost, the whole measurement operation will fail.

Beyond a reliable video and control interface, metrology sets major requirements on the image quality of a camera. The advantages of larger sensor resolutions of the latest CCD and global shutter CMOS image sensors come with several challenges since no component is perfect. Often these sensors come with clusters of defective pixels. The correction of these defects is done in the manufacturing process by interpolating between the good pixels in the surrounding of the defects. Since in metrology sharp edges of objects need to be detected and measured, large clusters of defect pixels reduce the consistently achievable accuracy. Most high-end camera manufacturers grade incoming sensors and reserve the best devices with few defective pixels for cameras that go into metrology applications.

Another challenge of high resolution sensors and a major differentiator is the quality of the sensor tap-balancing. High resolution CCD sensors are divided in taps in order to allow for a faster readout. However, each tap has its own processing pipeline with analog-digital conversion and amplifiers. Again, each of these components is unique, which usually results in different levels of brightness between the 2 or even 4 taps. The differences in brightness lead to artificial edges in the image and can mislead measurement algorithms.

The balancing of the taps is done in the FPGA of the camera and requires the calibration of numerous parameters during manufacturing of the camera. Theses parameters depend on exposure time, gain and sensor temperature. Only with an elaborate calibration method can cameras deliver optimal image quality with uniformity and linearity under most operation conditions.

 To conclude, in metrology systems for industrial automation and quality inspection higher camera resolution increases accuracy, high sensitivity allows for faster travel of the inspected objects and faster frame rates increase the throughput. The latest sensor technologies and interface standards allow metrology systems to meet these expectations. Aside from these improvements, the real differentiating factors for metrology cameras are the image quality, mechanical stability and reliability of the sensors, the read-out electronics, the camera interface, and software drivers. These are some of the critical aspects to be considered when it comes to the selection of system components for optical metrology applications. Most of them are not covered on datasheets and price lists but need the involvement of a trusted expert in the field so that the right components are selected to meet the application requirements.  

subscribe to Quality Magazine

Eric Ramsden is a product manager with Lumenera Corporation. For more information, visit www.lumenera.com.

Related Articles

Additive Manufacturing in Production Presents Challenges, Opportunities for Quality

Optical Metrology Solutions: The Future of Metrology

Optical Shaft Metrology: A New Generation of Measuring Systems Provides Cutting-Edge Precision, Accuracy

Case Studies: Challenges of Modern Body-in-White Inspection

Related Directories

VIEW Micro-Metrology

OGP (Optical Gaging Products)

Dorsey Metrology Intl.

RAM (RAM Optical Instrumentation)

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • Print & Digital Edition Subscriptions
  • eNewsletters
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service
  • Mobile Help

More Videos

Popular Stories

Automation in manufacturing

Automated Metrology: Manufacturing Trend of the Future

RoyalPower

Royal Power Solutions Opens Innovation Center

ASNT

ASNT Annual Conference Brings NDT to Las Vegas

EdmundsED

Edmund Optics Announces 2019 Educational Award, Norman Edmund Award Recipients

materials analysis

Rapid, Accurate Materials Analysis with a 2-Methods-In-1 Solution

Quality Leadership 100 Survey

Poll

Topics to Talk About

What topics would you like to see Quality cover more?
View Results Poll Archive

Products

Quality Brain Teasers: Real World Challenges to Build Your Manufacturing Skills (ebook)

Quality Brain Teasers: Real World Challenges to Build Your Manufacturing Skills (ebook)

Assessments and Training in the following areas...

See More Products

SoftwareDownloads

Quality Magazine

Quality December 2019

2019 December

Check out the December 2019 edition of Quality: Quality 4.0 for medical device manufacturing, automated metrology, gage trends, plastics, materials analysis and much more!
View More Create Account
  • Resources
    • Market Research
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • List Rental
    • Partners
    • Manufacturing Group
    • Polls
    • Privacy Policy
    • Survey and Sample
  • Want More
    • Connect

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing